This resource has been prepared by Nicholas dePencier Wright of Wright Business Law for educational purposes. This information is current as of the date of writing and does not constitute legal advice, which should be obtained prior to relying on anything herein.
Book a telephone consultation here: https://wrightbusinesslaw.cliogrow.com/book
_______________________________________________________________________________________
Estate Freezes in Canada: A Strategic Tool for Succession and Planning
Estate freezes are a popular tax-planning tool in Canada, particularly among business owners and high-net-worth individuals seeking to preserve family wealth and efficiently transfer assets to the next generation. Through an estate freeze, individuals can lock in the current value of their assets, allowing future growth to accrue to others (typically family members) while deferring or minimizing tax liabilities. This tool can be essential for business owners who want to ensure a smooth succession process and manage their tax obligations.
This article will explore what estate freezes are, the benefits they offer, and key considerations for implementing them.
- What is an Estate Freeze?
An estate freeze is a strategy that allows an individual to “freeze” the value of their current ownership in a business or other appreciating assets. This is achieved by converting shares or assets into a fixed-value interest, which “freezes” the current value for tax purposes. Any future growth or appreciation of the assets then accrues to new shareholders, typically family members or a family trust, who receive growth shares.
For example, a business owner might convert their common shares in a company into preferred shares with a fixed value. New common shares are then issued to the next generation, allowing them to benefit from future growth without the founder incurring immediate capital gains tax.
- When is an Estate Freeze Useful?
Estate freezes are particularly useful in these scenarios:
Succession Planning for Family-Owned Businesses: Business owners can use an estate freeze to transfer future business growth to family members while retaining control over the current value. This can ease the transition process and ensure continuity for the business.
Minimizing and Deferring Taxes: By freezing the value of assets now, individuals can manage the tax burden on future gains, effectively deferring capital gains tax until a future date, such as at death or disposition.
Income Splitting: Estate freezes allow for income-splitting opportunities. By allocating future growth shares to family members, it’s possible to distribute income more tax-efficiently among family members, reducing overall family tax liability.
Protecting Personal Wealth and Planning for Retirement: An estate freeze allows individuals to plan for retirement by securing a fixed-value interest in their business or assets. This fixed amount can provide income or serve as collateral if needed while preserving future growth for their heirs.
- How Does an Estate Freeze Work?
The process of implementing an estate freeze typically involves the following steps:
Valuation of Assets: The first step is to obtain a fair market value for the assets to be frozen. A qualified valuator, such as an accountant or business valuator, is often involved to ensure an accurate valuation, as this will determine the frozen value of the shares or assets.
Conversion of Shares or Assets: The individual exchanges their growth shares (such as common shares) in a corporation for fixed-value preferred shares, freezing their interest in the business at its current value.
Issuance of Growth Shares: New common shares, which hold the potential for future growth, are issued to family members or a family trust. These new shareholders will benefit from any appreciation in the company’s value going forward.
Establishing a Family Trust (Optional): In many cases, a family trust is created to hold the new growth shares. A family trust provides flexibility in allocating income and capital to beneficiaries, allowing for additional tax planning benefits.
Ongoing Compliance and Management: Once the freeze is in place, it’s important to manage and monitor the value of both the preferred shares and growth shares. Documentation must be kept to ensure compliance with Canada Revenue Agency (CRA) regulations, especially around fair market valuations.
- Benefits of an Estate Freeze
Tax Deferral on Capital Gains: Estate freezes help defer capital gains tax. By freezing the asset’s value at today’s level, the individual delays tax on any appreciation until the time of eventual disposition by the next generation.
Facilitates Business Succession: Estate freezes are ideal for intergenerational business transfers, ensuring a smooth transition without immediate tax costs. By freezing the owner’s stake, younger family members can begin accumulating value and assuming responsibility in the business.
Control and Income for the Freezor: The individual initiating the freeze (the “freezor”) retains control through preferred shares and can receive dividends on those shares. This allows them to maintain a stream of income while still passing future growth to family members.
Asset Protection and Income Splitting: Estate freezes allow for income splitting and asset protection through family trusts, helping to reduce overall family taxes. When growth shares are held by a trust, it’s easier to allocate future income to beneficiaries in lower tax brackets.
- Types of Estate Freezes
Estate freezes can be structured in different ways to suit an individual’s goals and family situation:
Direct Estate Freeze: In a direct freeze, the freezor exchanges their shares directly for fixed-value shares and issues growth shares to family members.
Freeze Through a Family Trust: Many individuals choose to issue growth shares to a family trust rather than directly to family members. A family trust offers more flexibility in distributing income and allows for the gradual transition of ownership and management over time.
“Hybrid” Freeze: In a hybrid structure, a combination of direct and trust-based strategies is used. For example, some growth shares might be allocated directly to family members, while others are held in trust. This approach provides flexibility for succession planning and income distribution.
- Important Considerations and Potential Pitfalls
Implementing an estate freeze is not without challenges. Here are some considerations and potential pitfalls:
Accurate Valuation is Essential: The CRA requires an accurate fair market valuation of the shares or assets being frozen. If valuations are off, it could result in unintended tax consequences or CRA audits.
Potential Attribution Rules: Under the Income Tax Act (Canada), if shares are transferred to family members or a family trust, income attribution rules may apply. Care must be taken to structure the freeze so that income earned by growth shares isn’t attributed back to the freezor.
Anti-Avoidance Provisions: The CRA applies General Anti-Avoidance Rules (GAAR) to ensure estate freezes aren’t used purely for tax avoidance. The freeze must demonstrate a legitimate business purpose, such as succession planning or facilitating family ownership.
Future Tax Implications: Although an estate freeze defers capital gains tax, it doesn’t eliminate it. The frozen value will eventually trigger tax liability, typically at the freezor’s death or upon the ultimate disposition of the assets by successors.
Legal and Professional Advice: Estate freezes are complex and should be undertaken with guidance from legal, tax, and valuation professionals. Mistakes in structuring or documenting the freeze could lead to costly tax penalties or loss of intended benefits.
- Practical Example of an Estate Freeze
Consider a successful Ontario-based business owner, Alex, who owns 100% of a corporation valued at $5 million. Alex wants to keep the business in the family and eventually pass it on to his children, but he also wants to avoid significant capital gains tax in the near term. By implementing an estate freeze, Alex can exchange his common shares for preferred shares valued at $5 million, freezing his interest in the company at that amount.
The corporation issues new common shares, which are purchased by a family trust set up for Alex’s children. As the business grows, the increase in value will accrue to the trust’s beneficiaries, while Alex retains control and income from the preferred shares.
This structure allows Alex to defer capital gains tax on the current value and enables a gradual transition of the business to his children.
- Conclusion
Estate freezes are a powerful tool for Canadian business owners and high-net-worth individuals seeking efficient succession and tax planning strategies. By freezing the value of assets today, estate freezes defer capital gains tax, facilitate family business continuity, and allow future growth to be passed on to the next generation.
Implementing an estate freeze requires careful planning, accurate valuations, and proper structuring. Working with experienced legal and tax professionals can help ensure the freeze is compliant with CRA regulations and tailored to meet the individual’s goals for wealth preservation and succession.
Sources:
Canada Revenue Agency
Income Tax Act, R.S.C. 1985, c. 1 (5th Supp.)
Canadian Tax Foundation